Agriculture

Galway farmer found guilty over threats in missing-dog dispute

Dawit BekeleOctober 19, 20265 min read11 views

At a glance

  • Judge Adrian Harris applied the Probation Act for one year after finding Brian Gill guilty in two incidents involving neighbour Brian Murphy.
  • A Co Galway farmer has been found guilty of using threatening and abusive words towards a neighbour in a dispute over a missing dog, but was not convicted after the judge applied the Probation Act.
Conceptual illustration of two farmers standing apart on a rural lane beside a stone wall, with a dog lead and an empty collar suggesting a missing dog.

A County Galway farmer has been found guilty of using threatening, abusive and insulting words towards a neighbour in a long-running dispute that centred on a missing dog, but he has avoided a criminal conviction.

At Gort District Court, Judge Adrian Harris found Brian Gill, 44, of Cahermore, Kinvara, guilty over two incidents, on 21 May 2025 and 2 February this year. The court heard the offences were committed with intent to provoke a breach of the peace.

Judge Harris did not convict Gill on either charge. Instead, he applied the Probation Act for one year and said Gill must complete an anger management course if the Probation Service recommends one. The judge said there was context to the offences and clear ill feeling between Gill and Brian Murphy stretching back some time.

Murphy told the court that during the May 2025 incident at Caherawoneen South, Kinvara, the two men met while driving on a narrow road at about 9pm. He said Gill accused him of stealing the dog and warned that he would get him. Murphy said he knew nothing about the dog and did not speak to Gill.

Gill denied threatening Murphy. He said he asked where his dog was and that Murphy called him a fool. Gill said he replied that Murphy was the only fool who sold topsoil from his farm. He told the court his dog went missing on 19 May 2025 and that he later received a call saying it had been found 35km away. He said the dog could not have walked that distance.

Gill also said he had been told by three people that the dog was seen in the back of Murphy’s yard, but he declined to identify them. He said he did not believe Murphy had the dog. Martin Durack, counsel for Gill, said there had been past disputes over fences and that Gill’s language may have been brusque but there was no threat or intention to cause a breach of the peace.

Reported by Dawit Bekele, Flow, Level and Utility Meter Specialist.